Environment
Fact-checked

At AllThingsNature, we're committed to delivering accurate, trustworthy information. Our expert-authored content is rigorously fact-checked and sourced from credible authorities. Discover how we uphold the highest standards in providing you with reliable knowledge.

Learn more...

What is the Difference Between Plants That Grow from Bulbs and Plants That Grow from Seeds?

A Kaminsky
A Kaminsky

Everyone loves a flower garden and most people would like to have one filled with color and fragrance. Many plants are available for using in a garden, and most of these come from either bulbs or seeds.

Most plants that come from seeds are either annuals or biennials. Annuals grow directly from seeds and grow, bloom and die in the course of one season. They also produce their own seeds. Many lovely flowers fall into this category, including most wildflowers, zinnias, marigolds, asters, daisies and petunias.

Cantaloupes grow from seeds, and are edible.
Cantaloupes grow from seeds, and are edible.

One nice option for using flowers from seeds is buying a roll of turf with the seeds already pre-planted. All a gardener needs to do is to unroll the turf in a suitable location and water it. These rolls are available at most garden centers. Biennials last for two years without replanting.

Other plants with seeds are edible, such as tomatoes, squash, cucumber, celery, berries, watermelon and cantaloupe. Packets of seeds for these vegetables can be found in the spring in grocery stores, home centers or from seed catalogs. Flower seeds are available as well.

Garlic grows from bulbs.
Garlic grows from bulbs.

Plants from bulbs are a whole other proposition. Probably the most famous plants growing from bulbs are tulips. However, daffodils, hyacinth, gladiolus and even garlic also spring from bulbs. Gardeners plant bulbs in the fall of the year and they remain dormant in the soil until spring. When the weather warms up, the bulbs send up green leaves, and eventually flower. The flowers remain for a couple of weeks or so, then they die back, and the leaves follow. These plants then lie dormant until the next spring, when they bloom again.

Most plants that grow from seed are either annuals or biennials.
Most plants that grow from seed are either annuals or biennials.

The main advantage with plant bulbs is that they can be moved to different places in the garden, depending on the gardener’s preferences. All the gardener has to do is to dig the bulbs up in the fall and replant them in the desired location. Plant bulbs are also available anywhere seeds and other plants are sold.

Planting bulbs and seeds is a wonderful family activity. Children can see the more or less immediate results of their labors with seeds in a pot, and can appreciate the virtues of patience when planting bulbs in autumn. This is a great experience for them to see where plants come from and how they grow.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the primary difference between plants that grow from bulbs and those that grow from seeds?

Daisies are annuals grown from seed.
Daisies are annuals grown from seed.

Plants that grow from bulbs have a storage organ that contains nutrients and embryonic parts of the plant, allowing them to survive dormant periods and regrow annually. In contrast, plants that grow from seeds start from a fertilized ovule that develops into a new plant, typically requiring germination each time they are planted.

How do the growth cycles of bulb and seed plants differ?

The seeds inside squashes are edible.
The seeds inside squashes are edible.

Bulb plants often have a perennial growth cycle, emerging each year from the same bulb, which stores energy for the plant's growth. Seed plants, on the other hand, usually complete their life cycle from germination to seed production within one growing season or over several years, depending on whether they are annuals, biennials, or perennials.

Are there any advantages to planting bulbs over seeds?

Plants with seeds are edible, like watermelon.
Plants with seeds are edible, like watermelon.

Planting bulbs can be advantageous as they typically require less maintenance after planting. Bulbs already contain the necessary nutrients for the initial growth spurt, leading to quicker and more reliable sprouting. They are also more resistant to adverse weather conditions and can provide a head start in growth compared to seeds.

Can bulb plants be propagated in ways similar to seed plants?

Yes, bulb plants can be propagated by dividing the main bulb into smaller bulblets or offsets, which can then be replanted to grow new plants. This method of vegetative propagation is similar to taking cuttings from seed plants, although seed plants can also be propagated by collecting and sowing seeds.

What types of plants typically grow from bulbs?

Many flowering plants grow from bulbs, including popular varieties such as tulips, daffodils, lilies, and hyacinths. These plants are favored for their ability to bloom year after year with minimal care once the bulbs are established in the ground or in pots.

Do bulb plants require special care compared to seed plants?

Bulb plants generally require less frequent care once established, but they do have specific needs. For instance, they often require well-drained soil to prevent rot and may need to be planted at a certain depth. After flowering, it's important to allow the foliage to die back naturally to replenish the bulb's nutrients for the next season.

Discussion Comments

TheGraham

@seHiro: Ooh, a bulb that blooms in the winter? That's awesome. Bulbs sound like they've got a lot of advantages, and I'll probably look into amaryllis bulbs for my garden, but really my favorite plants are mostly veggies, so you could say I'm a loyal seed gardener. Whatever fits for your gardening style, right?

seHiro

@aishia: Hi there! I agree on both of your points; bulbs can get eaten, and moisture can make them rot. If you watch for pests in the garden, though, and are careful not to plant bulbs in places where water could gather too much, bulbs are still just great. Daffodils and tulips are some of my favorites for spring, but my all-time favorite bulb is the amaryllis -- it blooms during the winter, and it's gorgeous!

aishia

@seHiro: Good post -- you're right, bulbs are really handy for the lazy gardener (like me!) A word of caution to anybody else out there who plans to plant things once and have an instant garden next year with zero effort: moles, insects and other critters can and will eat bulbs, so if nothing grows in the next year, that might be what happened! Also, too much moisture can make bulbs rot in the ground, killing the plants. In those regards, seed plants have the advantages.

seHiro

Another important thing to note about bulbs is that they come back year after year -- which is great if you're planting flowers in your yard on a budget and you don't mind seeing the same kinds of flowers year after year. In fact, if you don't like gardening at all, bulbs are handy -- you plant them once and your garden just grows in by itself every year after that for a long time! Different bulbs have different lifespans, though -- read up on how long they'll last if you want to plant them for a no-hassle garden.

Post your comments
Login:
Forgot password?
Register:
    • Cantaloupes grow from seeds, and are edible.
      By: Elena Schweitzer
      Cantaloupes grow from seeds, and are edible.
    • Garlic grows from bulbs.
      By: Schlierner
      Garlic grows from bulbs.
    • Most plants that grow from seed are either annuals or biennials.
      By: brozova
      Most plants that grow from seed are either annuals or biennials.
    • Daisies are annuals grown from seed.
      By: Friedberg
      Daisies are annuals grown from seed.
    • The seeds inside squashes are edible.
      By: zigzagmtart
      The seeds inside squashes are edible.
    • Plants with seeds are edible, like watermelon.
      By: bokan
      Plants with seeds are edible, like watermelon.